How Elon Musk Can Mitigate the Astronomy Impact of Starlink
Written on
Chapter 1: The Challenge of Light Pollution from Satellites
The introduction of satellite mega-constellations presents significant challenges for astronomers, disrupting observations and forcing scientific satellites to change trajectories. This text outlines how these issues can be addressed.
In various industries, the prevailing belief is that if there are no laws against a particular action, it is permissible to proceed without restraint. This often leads to the exploitation of resources until regulations are established, frequently harming those dependent on those resources. In the realm of astronomy, the most valuable asset is a dark, clear night sky, which serves as humanity's gateway to the cosmos. Traditionally, disturbances have come from turbulent atmospheres, cloud cover, and light pollution from urban areas. However, a new threat has emerged in the form of mega-constellations of satellites, with Elon Musk's Starlink project potentially jeopardizing ground-based astronomical research.
A Falcon 9 rocket from SpaceX launched 60 Starlink satellites on November 11, 2019, aiming to create a global high-speed internet network consisting of thousands of satellites. Unfortunately, the scientific cost of this initiative is already significant and likely to escalate in the future.
Section 1.1: Satellite Launches and Their Impact
The deployment of satellites is crucial for providing services like GPS and telecommunications, essential for modern life. With the advent of 5G technology, new infrastructure, including more satellites, is necessary. SpaceX, led by Elon Musk, is one of the pioneers in this area, planning to launch an initial 12,000 satellites as part of the Starlink mega-constellation, with an eventual total of 42,000 planned. Despite only 122 satellites being deployed by November 20, 2019, their adverse effects on global astronomy are already apparent.
This video discusses the potential dangers posed by Elon Musk's Starlink satellites to astronomical observations.
From the darkest locations on Earth, approximately 9,000 stars can be seen with the naked eye. However, the initial 122 Starlink satellites are brighter than most of these stars and move quickly across the sky, leaving trails that interfere with astronomical data collection. If these satellites were dimmer, fewer, or moved slowly, the issue would be less severe. But with a multitude of bright, fast-moving satellites, any frame capturing these artifacts must be discarded, complicating the work of astronomers.
Section 1.2: Specific Incidents of Interference
On November 18, 2019, 19 Starlink satellites passed over the Cerro Tololo Inter-American Observatory in Chile, significantly disrupting observations for over five minutes. Although this represents a small fraction (0.3%) of the proposed Starlink satellites, the implications are profound. Observatories focused on detecting faint celestial objects, like Pan-STARRS and LSST, will face considerable challenges. Ground-based observations cannot be planned to avoid these satellites, which frequently adjust their orbits and are highly conspicuous.
This video details scientific concerns regarding Starlink satellites potentially damaging the ozone layer, showcasing the broader environmental implications.
Chapter 2: Proposed Solutions to Mitigate Satellite Impact
The challenges posed by Starlink satellites can be addressed through responsible actions and modifications.
- De-orbit Existing Satellites: SpaceX should de-orbit current Starlink satellites and halt further launches until modifications are made. The existing satellites, currently at 280 km altitude, are visible to the naked eye and can be safely removed from orbit. Once raised to their operational altitude of 550 km, they become a permanent concern.
- Reduce Reflectivity: The design of the Starlink satellites is a choice that has led to their high reflectivity. By redesigning these satellites or applying a dark coating, the impact on astronomical observations can be diminished significantly.
- Real-Time Trajectory Information: Providing real-time data on satellite trajectories to observatories will allow astronomers to schedule their observations to avoid interference, maximizing data quality.
- Funding for Mitigation Efforts: SpaceX and similar companies should contribute financially to support astronomers in developing technologies to address satellite interference. This is a common practice across industries that impact the environment.
As the number of satellites continues to grow, it is imperative that companies involved take proactive measures to protect the night sky. The future of astronomical research hangs in the balance, dependent on the ethical practices of those launching satellites into orbit.