Chapter 1: Exploring the Collection

The literary legacy of David Graeber continues to flourish even after his untimely passing several years ago. His latest work, As If Already Free, stands out as it compiles an eclectic assortment of anthropological essays. Each piece is tied together by the profound impact of Graeber's writings, showcasing a remarkable breadth of topics.

Among the essays, one examines Eritrea's quest for independence alongside the contradictions of the Nobel Prize committee. Another delves into global birthing practices, while others explore themes like the history of central banks, the dynamics of anarchist anthropology, the aftermath of a coup in Myanmar, and the troubling trend of privatization in public universities. The collection features eleven essays, including an introduction that narrates Graeber’s journey to prominence and his connections with the contributors. The variety of perspectives is nothing short of impressive, with four essays penned by the editors, Holly High and Joshua Reno.

One of the essays creatively explores Graeber’s envisioned introduction to a new edition of another author’s work, which he never had the chance to complete. This imaginative approach connects to the precariousness of religious life in post-coup Myanmar, highlighting the significance of creativity in both Graeber's and the original author's perspectives. Graeber famously asserted that capitalism stifles creativity, emphasizing that it is imagination that distinguishes humans from other beings. While other creatures may possess reasoning skills, they lack the capacity for imagination.

The editors suggest that Graeber championed dialogue and learning through conversation. His life was a testament to this philosophy, reflected in his extensive commentary on a multitude of subjects. Graeber described his approach as beginning with seemingly bleak realities, seeking out hidden aspects that might offer a new perspective on an otherwise dismal situation. This method likely contributed to the captivating nature of his writing.

The inspirations for his thoughts are both profound and trivial. Graeber considered himself "a professional optimist," a notable claim given his experiences with political challenges in academia and the movements he engaged with, which he likely recognized as unlikely to succeed. Yet, these experiences birthed the idea of living "as if already free," which is also the title of this anthology.

He articulated that:

“To live as a rebel — in the constant awareness of the possibilities of revolutionary transformation and amongst those who dream of it — is surely the best way one can live.”

“It is plain to everyone that capitalism doesn’t work, but it is almost impossible for anyone to imagine anything else.”

“The war against the imagination is the only one the capitalists have actually managed to win.”

“When one tries to bring an imagined society into being, one is engaging in revolution.”

Reno’s essay, On Morons, likely takes the prize for the most unconventional topic. He reflects on his own son, whom he describes as a moron, lacking the ability to read, speak, or engage meaningfully in society. This leads to historical reflections on how societies have treated cognitively disabled individuals, from royal courtiers to revered fools. The essay traverses global perspectives on the treatment of the cognitively disabled, underlining the consistent mistreatment of these individuals.

Early in the piece, Reno references Graeber's thoughts from 2004, when he noted the disconnect between public perception and political outcomes, exemplified by the 2004 presidential debate between George W. Bush and John Kerry.

While I won't summarize every essay (as that would set an unmanageable precedent), it is evident that this collection is a significant homage to David Graeber, celebrating the diversity of thought and controversy inspired by his writings.

David Wineberg

(As If Already Free, Joshua Reno and Holly High, October 2023)

Chapter 2: Video Insights on Graeber's Legacy

In this section, we delve into two insightful videos that further explore David Graeber’s contributions to anthropology and his enduring influence.

The first video features the David Graeber LSE Anthropology Tribute Seminar on 'Myth', which discusses the profound themes present in Graeber's work.

The second video covers the David Graeber LSE Anthropology Tribute Seminar on 'Anarchist Anthropology', examining the principles of anarchist thought that Graeber championed throughout his career.